Showing posts with label Minimum Retirement Age. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Minimum Retirement Age. Show all posts

Monday, August 27, 2012

Malaysians not ready to retire?

Do you know that 4 out of 5 of today’s retirees in Malaysia worry about:

1. being poor and in need of money,
2. becoming a burden on their children, and
3. being “in ill health and having no one to care for them”

That is according to a recent survey.

All this point to the need for Malaysians to better plan and secure their financial position towards retirement. Would the implementation of the retirement age at 60 be of much help? If 55 years is not good enough a number, then neither is 60.

Not ready to retire
        Not ready to retire at 55, how about 60? Image: Seniors Aloud


The following article - a couple of days ago - by Bernama suggests that Malaysians may not be financially ready to retire:-


KUALA LUMPUR(Bernama): A study on retirement trends in East Asia has revealed the increasing vulnerability of Malaysians due to early retirement age as well as low rates of pension receipt under the Employees’ Provident Fund and the lack of old-age poverty floor.

The study report, “Balancing Tradition and Modernity: The Future of Retirement in East Asia”, is based on a survey that the Centre for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) conducted in Malaysia, China, Hong Kong, Singapore, South Korea and Taiwan, according to Prudential in a statement on the survey findings.

The CSIS East Asia Retirement Survey reveals that an astonishing 92 per cent of current retirees in Malaysia report that they had already left the workforce by age 60 and suggests that Malaysia’s pattern of premature retirement will likely persist. Malaysia is the only country in the survey whose fertility rate is above the 2.1 replacement level and the only one that will have a growing population and workforce in the coming decades, the report said.

“In China, the elderly share of the population will be approaching 30 per cent by 2040 — and in Hong Kong, Singapore, South Korea and Taiwan it will be approaching 40 per cent. In Malaysia, it will still be under 20 per cent,” it said.

Malaysia’s early mandatory retirement age, however, offsets its demographic advantage in building an adequate and sustainable retirement system, it added. Co-authored by Richard Jackson and Neil Howe, it is part of the multilayer Global Ageing Preparedness Project, which was launched by CSIS and British insurance giant Prudential plc in 2010.

The survey found four out of five of today’s retirees in Malaysia worry about “being poor and in need of money,” becoming “a burden on their children,” and being “in ill health and having no one to care for them” — much larger shares than in any of the other survey countries.

Their vulnerability is attributable to Malaysia’s unusually early retirement ages, which leaves retirees at risk of outliving their savings, as well as to low rates of pension receipt under the EPF and to the lack of an age-old poverty floor, the survey said. Retirement prospects are improving for the younger generations, who expect to be less dependent on the extended family than today’s retirees are and to rely more heavily on their own savings, it said.

But with one in five current workers still expecting to receive no pension benefits of any kind, the outlook for many is far from secure, it added. Donald Kanak, Chairman of Prudential Corporation Asia, which is part of Prudential plc, said: “Responding to the challenges caused by an ageing population is critical to Asia’s future.

“It is critical that policy makers and the industry work together to address this vital question.”

Charlie Oropeza, Chief Executive Officer of Prudential Assurance Malaysia Bhd, said: “The findings of the CSIS Study reinforce the need for Malaysians to better plan and secure their financial position towards retirement.

“While the policymakers as well as the Malaysian Government have been introducing frameworks such as the Financial Blueprint to provide greater length and breadth of financial products and services, Malaysians need to be more aware and make themselves financially ready through prudent investment decisions.

Thursday, July 19, 2012

EPF withdrawal stays at 55

I tried not to be overly critical to the people (hence the Government) who manage and run the country. In fact, you can find nothing in my previous 300 plus postings that is slanderous in nature. But the manner in which the current EPF issues is handled is quite ridiculous, or un-assuring if you like. Nobody seem to be assertive enough to give confirmation.

Let see what the executives responsible for handling it, have to say:
  1. Human Resource Minister Datuk Seri Dr S Subramaniam advised EPF subscribers not to believe in rumours or speculations that those from the private sector could only make their EPF withdrawal after they had reached 60 years old. No decision has been made yet.. (June 18, 2012. Kuala Lumpur).
  2. Deputy Finance Minister Datuk Donald Lim Siang Chai said “It is a consequential move. Once we raise the minimum retirement age, we have to raise the age of EPF withdrawal as well,”. Decision has been made...only a matter of time before the amendment is made.(The Star Online, July 17,2012)


This is what EPF Public Relations Manager, Nik Effendi Nik Jaafar said in today's local media, Daily Express:- "EPF withdrawal stays at 55 even if the retirement age is extended to 60 years old"

Image capture is appended herewith, so that you can quote me.

Daily Express, July 19, 2012


So, which is which? A little clarification is needed. Thank you.

Tuesday, July 17, 2012

Retirement age is raised to 60 - Consequently EPF withdrawal is at age 60

Because retirement age is raised from 55 to 60, full withdrawal of your EPF can only be made upon attaining age 60. At least that is what I understand from what I read in the local mainstream media today.




Last month, Human Resources Minister, Datuk Seri Dr S. Subramaniam clarified to the media in Kuala Lumpur that no decision has been made by the government on the age limit for the Employees Provident Fund (EPF) withdrawal for private sector employees yet. He advised EPF subscribers not to believe in rumours or speculations that those from the private sector could only make their EPF withdrawal after they had reached 60 years old.

Today, The Star Online reported that Deputy Finance Minister Datuk Donald Lim Siang Chai said 'the decision had been made and it was only a matter of time' before the amendment would come into effect.

If you ask me, I would like to see options. If I retire at age 55 instead of the (would be) mandatory retirement age of 60, I want to be able to withdraw my contributions at that age. Not everyone would want to retire at 60, mind you.

Leaving us with no option is one thing. Government ministers issuing contradicting statements about the amendment is not less than embarrassing. If you force me to keep my money with EPF for additional 5 years, then I won't stage a war with you. Just do it professionally without making yourselves look like a dis-organised institution.


Re-cap of The Star Online report:
Full EPF withdrawal at 60
July 17, 2012

PETALING JAYA: The age for full withdrawal from the Employees Provident Fund (EPF) by contributors will be raised to 60 years and partial withdrawal to 55.

The planned amendment to the Employees Provident Fund (EPF) Act 1991 follows the passing of the Minimum Retirement Age Bill 2012 in Parliament last month which extends the minimum retirement age for private sector employees from 55 to 60.

“It is a consequential move. Once we raise the minimum retirement age, we have to raise the age of EPF withdrawal as well,” said Deputy Finance Minister Datuk Donald Lim Siang Chai.

He said the decision had been made and it was only a matter of time before the amendment would come into effect. Currently, contributors can make partial EPF withdrawal at 50 and full withdrawal of their savings upon retirement at 55.

However, Lim said they were looking at providing a transition period for contributors who have already planned to withdraw their contributions within the next few years.

“We have not finalised the transition period, but it will be between three and five years,” he said adding that during this period, contributors who reached the age of 55 could still make full withdrawals.EPF contributors had expressed concern about whether the age for full EPF withdrawal would be raised.

You can read further at: http://thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2012/7/17/nation/11676473&sec=nation

Tuesday, June 19, 2012

EPF withdrawal at age 60: are you in favour?

"Don't believe a word. They're just rumours or speculations".

That was what the Human Resources Minister clarified to the media in Kuala Lumpur, Tuesday. According to him, no decision has been made yet by the government on the age limit for the Employees Provident Fund (EPF) withdrawal for private sector employees.


Daily Express, 19-06-2012


Re-cap of Bernama report

KUALA LUMPUR, June 18 -- No decision has been made by the government on the age limit for the Employees Provident Fund (EPF) withdrawal for private sector employees, Human Resource Minister Datuk Seri Dr S Subramaniam said today. He advised EPF subscribers not to believe in rumours or speculations that those from the private sector could only make their EPF withdrawal after they had reached 60 years old.

He said this in response to concerns raised by EPF subscribers over the age limit for EPF withdrawals, following the tabling of the Minimum Retirement Age Bill in Parliament last Wednesday, which set the minimum retirement age for private sector employees at 60, effective January next year.

Speaking to reporters after opening a seminar on improving the administrative system of Social Organisations here, Subramaniam said the ministry understood the concerns raised by subscribers and would discuss the matter with the EPF. In another development, he said the ministry was in discussions with EPF to introduce a special pension scheme for private sector employees to address the problems of poverty and the high cost of living once they retire.

"No decision has been made and we will continue to discuss the matter with the EPF," he added.


TheGreenMechanics' two cents:

The Minimum Retirement Age Bill should be a straight forward exercise which should not be complicated with tying it with the EPF withdrawal rules. Rumour has it that an employee would finish up his EPF retirement savings just after 3 to 5 years from the withdrawal date. If that is the reason for the rumoured extension of EPF withdrawal age to 60 then I feel it is very unfair on the part of the government.

You (the govt) have already extended the minimum retirement age from 55 to 60; meaning you've taken care  of additional 5 years of that employee's welfare. Moreover, during the additional 5 years of working the employee is fully contributing to his 'extended' retirement coffers.

Leave the man (and woman) alone. Let him withdraw at current age limit of 55, remember it's his money he's been saving according to the law till age 55. Don't amend the law to withhold what is rightfully his.

It's still a long shot but I want to state what I want for myself long in future: I want my money at 55 and not 60. I am fully entitled to it and I want and can manage it better than EPF does.